Checking statement 2 against the hall’s own terms
Ana has the four statements above. Should she cancel now and expect the $120 back, and which statement decides that?
Starting state
The deposit is $120, the room hire is $240 and the event is 20 days away. Ana’s booking confirmation says the hall’s terms on its website apply to her booking. She has not seen those terms yet.
Choose the claim to check first.
Why this step
Statement 1 decides what Ana does and rests on statement 2, so statement 2 goes first. If it is false, statements 1 and 3 fall with it.
What changes
Statement 2: the hall refunds deposits in full when you cancel at least 14 days before. With 20 days left, it says Ana could cancel free today.
Say what would make it false, and where the truth is kept.
Why this step
The route must not pass through the assistant, which holds no copy of the terms and has only a guess at what such terms usually say. The hall wrote its terms, so the hall’s own page is where they are kept.
What changes
The claim is false if the terms give a different number of days or a different refund. Ana opens the terms page her confirmation points to.
Copy the cancellation wording exactly.
Why this step
A paraphrase is where numbers get changed. Copied words keep the comparison honest.
What changes
The page reads: “Cancellation. 28 or more days before the event: the deposit is refunded in full. From 8 to 27 days before: the deposit is kept. 7 days or fewer before: the full room hire of $240 is payable, with the deposit counted towards it.”
Compare statement 2 with the wording, number against number.
Why this step
The days and the amount are the two details that carry the decision, so they are compared one at a time.
What changes
The refund in full matches. The number of days does not: the statement says 14 and the page says 28.
Apply the page to Ana’s date and to statement 3.
Why this step
A check is not finished until you see what it changes for the person acting on it.
What changes
At 20 days Ana falls in the second line, so cancelling now loses the $120 deposit instead of returning it. Statement 3 fails too: at 7 days or fewer the full $240 is payable, with the deposit counted towards it, so the most she could lose is $240 in total, not $120.
Decide how much more checking the stakes justify.
Why this step
This is a $120 to $240 decision, and the hall’s own published words are clear, so the page is enough to act on today. If the sums were larger, the wording unclear, or her confirmation and the page in disagreement, she would also ask the hall in writing.
What changes
Ana stops here. She saves the copied wording and the date she read it.
Result
Statement 2 had the wrong number, 14 days where the hall says 28, and statements 1 and 3 fell with it. Cancelling now would cost Ana the $120, not return it, and the worst case is $240 in total, the $120 already paid plus $120 more, once the event is 7 days away or less. Cancelling on any day from now until 8 days before costs the $120, so she can wait for the client’s answer, but not past that point. Statement 4, asking the hall in writing about a transfer, is sound and she follows it.