Worked example: two datasets, two different outcomes
示例
Dataset A: captured in a public plaza, no consent records, offered under a permissive resale license. Dataset B: captured under a signed site agreement whose consent scope covers third-party resale, licensed for resale but with sublicensing restricted to end-products only. For each dataset, determine whether resale is defensible and on what terms.
演示讲解
Dataset A — check each gate in order.
License gate: the license is permissive and would allow resale. This gate opens.
Consent gate: no consent records exist for the people and property captured in the public plaza. The consent scope does not cover resale, and consent cannot be obtained retroactively for a capture that already happened. This gate fails.
Regulatory gate: not reached, because the consent gate already blocks the resale.
Result for A: resale is not defensible. The permissive license is irrelevant because consent independently fails.
Dataset B — check each gate in order.
License gate: the license grants resale, so this gate opens. However, the sublicensing restriction limits the form of transfer: the data may be resold as an end-product, not as raw data.
Consent gate: the site agreement's scope explicitly covers third-party resale, so this gate opens for the intended use.
Regulatory gate: no regime restriction is stated for this transfer, so this gate opens.
Result for B: resale is defensible, but only in the permitted form. The dataset may be sold as an end-product; selling the raw data would exceed the sublicensing restriction and fail the license gate for that specific use.