Module 1 · Replace rereading with testing and spacing
Lesson 2 of 6 · 7 min · English · Read-only
Retrieval practice means answering from memory with the source closed and then checking; it works when each question makes you produce the answer without handing it over in its wording and asks for one thing, and when you answer before you look.
Retrieval practice means answering a question from memory with your source closed, then checking the answer. It is the method behind the 2006 result in lesson 1, and it is also called self-testing. The finding that testing yourself improves later memory more than extra reading is called the testing effect. The Dunlosky paper reports that more than a century of research has produced several hundred experiments, and it rated practice testing high in usefulness because the benefit held across question formats, materials, ages and delays. Why it works is still debated. One account is that searching memory for an answer links the item to related ideas, which gives later searches more paths to it.
A question only helps if it makes you produce the answer, and three tests tell you whether yours does. First: could you get it right without knowing the thing? A true-or-false question can be guessed, and a sentence with one word missing can often be finished from its shape. Second: does the wording contain the answer? If the question uses the answer’s own key words, it hands them to you. Third: does it ask for one thing? A two-part question gets a half-right answer that you cannot mark.
On question formats, the paper says the available evidence suggests that recall or short-answer questions work better than fill-in-the-blank or recognition questions, though its authors say more work is needed before strong rules.
Mix the kinds of question. Fact questions (what does this do?) check the pieces. Why questions check that you know the reason. Use questions give you a new case to apply the pieces to. Testing benefits have been found for application questions too, although most of the research used fact questions. Start mostly with fact questions and add a few why and use questions; the notes below give six fact questions, one why and one use.
The same works from a video or a course: pause every few minutes, write one question about what you just heard, and answer it later with your notes closed.
Inspect the artifact
document3 annotationsChapter 3 notes: cell partsNucleus: stores the cell’s DNA, the instructions for building proteins.Ribosome: builds proteins by following a copy of those instructions, called mRNA.Rough endoplasmic reticulum (rough ER): a membrane network covered with ribosomes; the proteins made there are folded inside it.Golgi apparatus: modifies, sorts and packages proteins into vesicles, small membrane-wrapped bubbles.Lysosome: breaks down worn-out parts and waste with digestive enzymes.Mitochondrion: uses oxygen to turn food molecules into ATP, the energy the cell spends.Muscle cells contain many mitochondria because contraction uses a lot of ATP.A protein released from the cell: made on the rough ER, then the Golgi apparatus, then a vesicle that joins the cell membrane.Eight lines of notes became eight questions: six ask what a part does, one asks why, and one asks you to use the parts on a new case. Lesson 3 reuses six of these questions and lesson 5 reuses all eight.
Artifact content has 9 lines and 3 annotations.
Four questions aim at the same note, line 5 above: the Golgi apparatus modifies, sorts and packages proteins into vesicles. A. True or false: the Golgi apparatus packages proteins. B. The Golgi apparatus modifies, sorts and (blank) proteins. C. A newly made protein arrives at the Golgi apparatus. What happens to it there? D. What does the Golgi apparatus do, and what does the lysosome do?
Predict before the next step
Apply the three tests to each wording: could you get it right without knowing the thing, does the wording hand you the answer, does it ask for one thing? Which of the four pass all three?
Your writing stays on this page only. It is not saved or assessed.
A, true or false. Test 1 fails, because a guess is right half the time. Test 2 fails, because the question states the answer, so a reader who half remembers the sentence simply agrees. Test 3 passes.
B, the sentence with a gap. Test 1 fails: the gap can be filled from how the sentence sounds (“modifies, sorts and …”) without knowing what a Golgi apparatus does. Test 2 fails: two of the three jobs are written out. Test 3 passes.
C, the open question with a case. Test 1 passes: nothing in it can be finished by shape, and a guess has to be a full sentence. Test 2 passes: the question names no job, and the words modifies, sorts and packages appear nowhere in it. Test 3 passes: one situation, one answer, which is what happens to the protein.
D, two questions in one. Test 3 fails. Someone who answers one half well and misses the other has no clear mark. Split it into one question for the Golgi apparatus and one for the lysosome.
Fixing a failing question usually means taking words out, not adding them.
Result
only C passes all three tests. A and B check whether you recognize the sentence, D has to be split, and C checks whether you can say what the Golgi apparatus does.
Put your notes out of sight and read one question.
Write the answer in a sentence, or say it aloud, before anything else. If nothing comes, write “blank”. Glancing at the notes after a second or two is rereading, not a test.
Open the notes and compare. Lesson 5 covers how to mark an answer well.
For any miss, close the notes and write the correct answer from memory once. It takes seconds and shows the correction took; the lasting benefit comes from asking it again tomorrow (lesson 3).
Keep all your questions in one pile, as cards or a list, and leave the missed ones in it for the next session. Lesson 3 covers when that session should be.
Think it over
Without scrolling back, can you list the three tests a good question passes? Check against the lesson, then rewrite one question from your own notes until it passes all three.