Module 2 · Mix, check and run it
Lesson 5 of 6 · 7 min · English · Read-only
Check every answer against points you wrote before the test, write your confidence before you look, and name each miss as blank, mix-up, incomplete or unclear question; a confident wrong answer is the most useful miss to find, and each kind has its own fix.
A self-test does half its work if you skip the check. Marking an answer against the source corrects what you got wrong and tells you which questions to bring back soon. Dunlosky and colleagues’ review reports that practice testing with feedback consistently beat testing alone. In one study it cites, students who took a multiple-choice practice test without feedback later gave more wrong answers drawn from the test’s false options, an increase that did not appear when feedback was given.
The same paper adds three things. Feedback does not have to arrive straight after the test. Evidence it cites suggests feedback is especially effective for errors made with high confidence. And the harm from wrong answers on a practice test is small and usually outweighed by the benefit, so hard questions are no reason to stop testing, as long as you check the answers.
Three habits make the check count. First, write what a complete answer contains, taken from your notes, before you test: these are the points. Second, write your answer, then your confidence in it, sure or not sure, and only then check. Third, mark by points and name the kind of miss, because each kind has its own fix.
The rating is a common practice, not something shown to improve memory by itself. Its use is that it turns the feeling of knowing, which lesson 1 showed to be unreliable, into something you can compare with your results.
Confidence and result give four cases. Sure and right: the item is holding, so move it up its ladder. Sure and wrong: fix this first, because it is the answer you would have given with confidence on the day. Not sure and right: it is holding but shaky, so repeat its gap instead of moving it up. This is one change to lesson 3’s rule. Not sure and wrong: expected, so send it back to the 1-day gap.
Inspect the artifact
text6 annotationsQuestion: What does the Golgi apparatus do to the proteins it receives?Points a complete answer needs, written from my notes before the test: 1. modifies them 2. sorts them 3. packages them into vesiclesMy answer, written with the notes closed: “It packages proteins.”My confidence, written before checking: sureMarked: 1 of 3 points. Not right.Kind of miss: incomplete. I knew one job and took it for the whole job.Next: ask it again tomorrow, scored by the three points.Artifact content has 10 lines and 6 annotations.
Take lesson 3’s day-1 session and add two questions, muscle cells and the rough ER, plus a confidence rating written before each check. The results below are assumptions of the example. Nucleus: sure, right. Mitochondrion: not sure, right. Muscle cells (why so many mitochondria?): sure, right. Rough ER: sure, right. Golgi apparatus: sure, 1 of 3 points. Lysosome: sure, wrong, answered with the ribosome’s job. Ribosome: not sure, blank. Protein route: not sure, wrong, left out the rough ER.
Predict before the next step
How many answers were right? How many of the “sure” answers were right? Which misses come first?
Your writing stays on this page only. It is not saved or assessed.
Tally the results. Right: nucleus, mitochondrion, muscle cells and rough ER, which is 4 of 8, half.
Now split by confidence. Sure: nucleus, muscle cells, rough ER, Golgi apparatus and lysosome. That is 5 answers, 3 right and 2 wrong. Not sure: mitochondrion, ribosome and protein route. That is 3 answers, 1 right and 2 wrong. The two groups add to 8 answers and 4 right. Being sure was right 3 times in 5, or 60 percent. That is the number to watch: until “sure” is right nearly every time, it is not a reliable signal.
Priorities. The Golgi apparatus and the lysosome come first, because the learner was sure and wrong on both and no feeling would have flagged them. Sort them with the table. The Golgi apparatus is incomplete, one job of three, so write the three points under it. The lysosome is a mix-up with the ribosome, so write the one-line difference and practise the two together. The ribosome is blank, so relearn it from the notes. The protein route is incomplete, so write the whole route in order.
Schedule, using lesson 3’s ladder with this lesson’s change. Nucleus, muscle cells and rough ER are sure and right, so they move up and are due on day 4. The mitochondrion is right but not sure, so it repeats its 1-day gap: due on day 2, with the four misses. That change is why it no longer jumps to day 4 as it did in lesson 3’s trace, which had no ratings. Day 2 holds 5 questions: mitochondrion, Golgi apparatus, lysosome, ribosome and protein route. Day 4 holds 3. 5 plus 3 is the 8 questions.
Result
half right, “sure” right 60 percent of the time, the two sure-and-wrong answers fixed first, five questions due on day 2 and three on day 4.
Think it over
Before scrolling up, say what lesson 3’s ladder, with this lesson’s change, does with a question you answer right but are not sure of; then name the kind of miss in the last answer you got wrong in any subject, and whether you were sure when you gave it.