Module 2 · Mix, check and run it
Lesson 4 of 6 · 7 min · English · Read-only
Interleaved practice mixes kinds of question within a session instead of finishing one kind first; it helps most when you must decide which idea applies and it often scores lower while you practise, and because the evidence is less settled than for testing and spacing, a common rule is to learn each topic alone first and then mix.
Take ten questions: five on osmosis and five on active transport. Doing all five on osmosis and then all five on active transport is blocked practice. Alternating them, so that no two neighbours are alike, is interleaved practice, also called mixed practice. The case for mixing is about decisions. In a run of five osmosis questions you know what kind comes next, so you only carry out the method. In a mixed set you must first decide which kind of question this is, and in a real test nobody tells you.
In one study described in the Dunlosky paper, college students learned to find the volumes of four kinds of solid. During practice the blocked group scored higher than the mixed group. On a test a week later the order reversed and the mixed group scored higher. A mixed set can score worse while you practise and still serve you better later, so do not judge it by its practice score alone.
This is less settled than testing and spacing. Dunlosky and colleagues’ review rated interleaving moderate, not high, because there are fewer studies and the results vary: in college students it sometimes helped and sometimes did not, depending on the task and on how much practice came first. The clearest results are for items you must tell apart, such as which kind of problem or category a question belongs to.
The paper also notes that most studies introduced every topic before mixing began, and one study found partial support that beginners gain from some blocked practice first. So the rule in the table below, block first and then mix, is common practice, not a proven rule.
Chapter 3 also covers the four ways small molecules, ions and water cross the membrane, in the table above. Large molecules leave in vesicles, as in lesson 2. Moving down a concentration difference means moving from where there is more of a substance to where there is less. Name the kind of crossing in each situation.
Predict before the next step
Before you read on, name the kind of crossing in all eight, and notice where you hesitate.
Your writing stays on this page only. It is not saved or assessed.
Each situation needs a decision before any recall, which is what the mixed order forces. Ask three questions in this order. Is energy spent moving something against the difference? Then it is active transport: situations 4 and 7. If not, is the thing moving water? Then it is osmosis: situations 2 and 5. If not, does it need a channel or carrier protein? Then it is facilitated diffusion: situations 3 and 6. If not, it is diffusion: situations 1 and 8.
In a blocked set the kind is given. Written in blocks, as 1 and 8, then 2 and 5, then 3 and 6, then 4 and 7, you would know each pair’s kind before reading it, so you would only apply the method. In the mixed order nothing announces the kind, so each of the eight situations needs its own decision first.
Two pairs deserve a second look. Situations 2 and 5 both involve water moving toward more dissolved substance. Osmosis is really diffusion of water; this scheme names it separately, so when water is the thing moving, answer osmosis. Situation 3 uses a carrier protein and situation 7 a pump protein, but only 7 spends ATP and moves ions against the difference, so it is active transport and situation 3 is facilitated diffusion.
Result
1 diffusion, 2 osmosis, 3 facilitated diffusion, 4 active transport, 5 osmosis, 6 facilitated diffusion, 7 active transport, 8 diffusion. Reading a mixed set well means deciding the kind first and recalling the facts second.
Write the topic on each question. Test each topic alone until you get most of its questions right. A common starting rule is about 70 percent, which is a working number, not a research threshold; with only two or three questions on a topic, read it as “most of them”. Then shuffle the topics together so that no two neighbours share a topic.
Expect a lower score than in single-topic sets, and compare it with your last mixed score, not with your blocked ones.
Think it over
Which two topics in your own subject do you most often confuse, and what one question for each could be answered correctly only by someone who can tell the two apart?