How far does one leaked password reach?
Example
Priya has the nine accounts in the diagram. She typed the same password, X, on accounts 1 to 4. Shop A, account 2, is breached through no fault of hers, and the leaked list holds her email address and X. Assume a criminal tries that pair on her other accounts and uses reset links wherever the password fails. How many of the nine can they take over?
Predict before the next step
Guess before you read on: how many of the nine accounts end up in the criminal’s hands?
Your writing stays on this page only. It is not saved or assessed.
Walkthrough
Start with the leak. Shop A gives up the pair: 1 account.
The same pair works on accounts 1, 3 and 4, because they also use X. That is 3 more, 4 in all, and one of them is the email.
With the inbox open, the criminal presses “forgot password” on accounts 5 to 9, which have different passwords, and opens each reset link. That is 5 more.
4 + 5 = 9 of 9. Five of those accounts had passwords that nobody ever stole.
Now change one condition. Priya gives every account its own password and changes nothing else. The leak from shop A holds a password that works only on shop A. The criminal gets 1 of 9, and the email stays closed.
Change a different condition instead. Priya keeps X on accounts 1 to 4 but adds a second sign-in step to her email account (lesson 3). X still opens accounts 2, 3 and 4, so the criminal has 3 of 9, but the email stops them at the second step. Accounts 5 to 9 never produce a reset link they can open.
The two changes guard different things. A unique password stops one leak from spreading. A second step on email stops the reset route when a password has leaked. It helps less when a password is handed to a fake page: lesson 3 shows which second steps a fake page can defeat, and lesson 4 shows how to spot the page. With both in place, the same leak reaches 1 of 9: the shop that was breached.