Module 2 · Verify, back up, recover
Lesson 4 of 6 · 7 min · English · Read-only
You cannot reliably tell a scam from a real message by how it looks, so decide by checking: contact the organization or person through an app, number or address you already trust and started yourself, never through details in the message.
A scam message can have perfect spelling, the right logo and your name in the greeting. The UK’s National Cyber Security Centre warns that AI tools let criminals write lures without the spelling and grammar mistakes that often reveal phishing, so clean text proves nothing. So “does this look real?” is the wrong question. The useful one is “did I start this?” If you did not, check the request another way before you act.
Another way means a channel you already trust and the sender did not supply: the app already on your phone, the number printed on your card, a website address you type yourself, a number saved in your contacts for a person. The link, the phone number, the “reply here” and the “stay on the line” that arrive with a request all belong to the sender’s channel, and a criminal controls the sender’s channel. Even the name and number a call shows can be faked.
Checking costs about a minute. A real bank, delivery company or relative can wait a minute. Pressure not to wait tells you something on its own. If you are unsure, talk it over with someone you trust before you act.
The pressure follows a pattern. The sender claims to be an organization or a person you know, announces a problem or a prize, demands that you act now, and asks you to pay in a way that is hard to get back: gift cards, a transfer, a payment app, cryptocurrency, or a check you are told to deposit before sending money back. The message below, invented for this course, shows most of it.
Inspect the artifact
document6 annotationsFrom: Exampleton Bank Security <alerts@exampletonbank.secure-login.example.net>Subject: URGENT: your account will be limited today Dear customer, We detected an unusual sign-in to your account from a new device.To keep your money safe, confirm your identity within 2 hours or youraccount will be limited and your card cancelled. Confirm now: https://exampletonbank.secure-login.example.net/verify You will receive a one-time code by text. Reply to this message withthe code, your card number and its expiry date. Exampleton Bank Security TeamA real scam can get every one of these tells right: your real name, clean spelling, a link that looks right. What stays is the ask and the clock, and checking through your own channel answers both without inspecting anything.
Artifact content has 15 lines and 6 annotations.
A channel the sender gave you
The link in the message. The number to call or text in it. A reply to the message. A caller who says “stay on the line and I will transfer you”. A call-back number left in a voicemail. Whoever sent the request controls every one of these, so a criminal controls them too.
A channel you started
The bank’s app, opened from the icon already on your phone. The number printed on the back of your card. A website address you type yourself. For a request that seems to come from someone you know, the number you already had saved for that person. The sender cannot reach any of these.
Think it over
For your bank and one other organization that contacts you, what is the channel you would use to check a message, and where does its number or address come from?
The message above lands in Priya’s inbox on her phone. What does she do, and why does none of it depend on the message?
Only the preview has been read. Priya has the bank’s app installed and her bank card in her wallet. She did not start any sign-in just now.
Leave the message alone: no tap on the link, no reply, no “unsubscribe”.
Why this step
The link and the reply are the sender’s channel, and any response tells the sender the address is live.
What changes
Nothing has happened yet. The message sits in the inbox.
Open the bank’s app from its icon and look for an alert or a message inside it.
Why this step
The app is a channel the bank controls and Priya started.
What changes
No alert, no limit on the account and no message in the app’s inbox.
If she is still unsure, call the number printed on the back of her card and ask whether the bank sent it.
Why this step
The card is a channel she holds, and the number did not come from the sender.
What changes
The bank says it sent nothing like it.
Report the message with the mail app’s report option, then delete it.
Why this step
Reports help get the sender’s address and page shut down.
What changes
The message leaves her inbox and the report is sent.
Nothing was typed, paid or read out. Priya never had to decide whether the message looked real, because the app and the bank answered the question. Had the app shown a real alert, she would have dealt with it inside the app.
Change one condition: the same demand arrives as a phone call from “the fraud team”, and the caller already knows her name and the last four digits of her card. Her move is identical: hang up and call the number on her card. A few correct details prove nothing, because details leak from breaches and public sources. If she has already paid or typed details, she skips to lesson 6, whose first step is the bank.