Module 1 · From idea to evidence
Lesson 2 of 6 · 7 min · English · Read-only
Ask people to describe specific things they did, spent and tried in the past: those stories are evidence about the problem, while praise and promises about your idea are not.
Ask people to tell you about specific things that happened to them, not whether they would like your idea. Maya’s first assumption is that cyclists put off servicing because shop hours clash with work. To check it she needs conversations, and the kind of question she asks decides whether the answers are worth anything.
“Tell me about the last time your bike needed work” gets a story with dates, places, money and workarounds, and a story has details you can ask about. Questions about the future or about your idea get opinions. Opinions about your idea tend to be polite: nobody likes telling you to your face that your plan is weak, and nobody can reliably predict what they will do next month.
Three rules cover most of it. Do not mention your idea until the end, if at all: once you pitch, the person starts judging the pitch instead of describing their life. Ask what happened, what it cost and what they tried before you ask what they think. Talk to people who had the problem recently, not to friends and family, who know you and will be kind.
A common starting point is somewhere between five and ten conversations. Stop sooner if every answer repeats, and keep going if answers keep surprising you. Take notes on facts, not impressions: what they did, when, what it cost, what else they tried. Write compliments down separately and give them no weight.
Maya has now had eight conversations like Dev’s, found in the bike room of the building where she lives and among her shop’s customers. The building she will test in lesson 4 is a different one. Her tally is invented for this example. Seven had bike trouble in the past year. Five of those seven left the bike at a shop for a day or more. Three of those five changed how they got to work while it was away. One had paid someone to come to them. No one has been shown $60 for a tune-up at work yet. The only prices in her notes are what people paid in the past, such as the $70 Dev paid a shop.
Read the tally for what it is. It counts conversations: five of eight, not “five in eight cyclists”. Her eight are probably keener cyclists than most, because she met them at a bike shop and in a bike room, so the tally says the problem exists for some people and says nothing about how many. It fits her assumption that cyclists put servicing off, since Dev has still not fixed his bike, and it does not show how urgent the need is. And it says nothing about whether anyone will pay $60 to have the problem solved.
A conversation can show that a problem exists. It cannot show that someone will pay for your answer to it, because saying yes or naming a price costs nothing. That needs evidence of another kind, and the next lesson sorts evidence by strength.
Think it over
Write the one question you most want potential customers to answer about your idea, then rewrite it as a question about the last time they faced the problem. Name three people who had the problem recently and do not know you well.
Inspect the artifact
document7 annotationsMaya: Tell me about the last time your bike needed work.Dev: March. The chain kept skipping. I took it to a shop near thestation on a Saturday.Maya: What happened when you got there?Dev: They were booked solid and kept it four days, so I took thetrain. That added about 40 minutes each way.Maya: What did you do before you picked that shop?Dev: Called two others. One closed at five, the other could nottake it for a week.Maya: What did it cost?Dev: Seventy dollars, plus the train tickets.Maya: I am thinking of doing tune-ups here in the bike room.Dev: Oh, great idea. I would totally use that.Maya: What have you done about the bike since March?Dev: Nothing, honestly. It still shifts badly. I keep meaning to.Maya: Who else here rides to work?Dev: Priya and Tom. Tom fixes his own.Artifact content has 17 lines and 7 annotations.