Change one thing, then read the second result
Example
Maya’s first test ended with 4 counted deposits from the 60 cyclists reached, which her card sends to “change one thing, run once more.” Those 60 have seen the offer and cannot be asked again, so the rerun needs a fresh group: a second building, different from the one where she lives, whose bike-room list also has 60 cyclists. Its manager has agreed, as the first did, to the bike-room afternoon and one email. What does she change, what does she hold fixed, and what happens after the second result? Assume the second test ends with 1 deposit, from a stranger, and no others.
Walkthrough
Step 1. Choose the one change. The fresh group is already a change, so she keeps it as the only one. She could also rewrite the headline, but a weak second result could then not say whether the building or the headline was to blame. A lower price is no quick alternative: lesson 4 showed that a cut to $50 raises the pass mark to 6 bikes and breaks the half-day visit.
Step 2. Hold everything else fixed: the headline, $60, the $20 deposit credited against it, 5 slots, 10 days, a reach of all 60, the counting rule and the zones. The new card differs from the first only in the building.
Step 3. Write the expectation first. If the first count was typical of office-building cyclists, the second building should land near it, in the middle zone or above. The pass mark stays at 5 because nothing that sets it has changed: the price, the supplies, the visit length and her $200 floor.
Step 4. Read the second result. The manager confirms the email reached all 60, and the one deposit counts. That is the stop zone. Across both groups, 4 + 1 = 5 deposits from 60 + 60 = 120 cyclists reached, which is one in 24 (120 ÷ 5 = 24). A full visit needs 5 deposits, which is one in twelve of those reached. Across 120 cyclists that rate would be 10 deposits, twice as many as came. So the 4 was not a sign that a pass was close.
Step 5. Decide. The second result alone is in the stop zone, so the card says stop. A third try of the same offer on new people would be rerunning until a count passes.
Result
Maya stops selling this version: $60 per tune-up with a refundable $20 deposit, offered through a manager’s email to cyclists in office buildings. The tests do not show why it fell short. The headline, the price, trust, and the manager’s email as the way in are all still untested.