Five replies to the same message
Example
Suppose Maya sent this to five cyclists in the building where she lives: “I’m planning bike-room tune-ups for $60, with a first visit next month. Interested?” The five replies are invented for this example. Ana writes: “Love this!! Great idea.” Ben writes: “I’d definitely use that. I’d pay $50, easily.” Chloe sends her email address. Dmitri books a 15-minute call for Friday, brings a list of what is wrong with his bike and introduces a colleague. Eun pays a $20 deposit to hold a slot, credited against the $60 and refundable until 24 hours before the visit. What does each reply tell Maya, and what can she honestly report?
Predict before the next step
Rank the five replies by how much each tells Maya about whether people will pay $60.
Your writing stays on this page only. It is not saved or assessed.
Walkthrough
Step 1. Cost to the giver. Ana: nothing. Ben: nothing, and his $50 is a guess that is $10 below the price. Chloe: a minute. Dmitri: 15 minutes and his name on an introduction. Eun: $20 on the line, one third of the price (20 ÷ 60), and refundable.
Step 2. Match to the assumption. The assumption is about money, so only Eun’s reply sits on the rung it needs. Dmitri’s call and list show that the problem matters to him, which strengthens the problem assumption. They say nothing about his wallet.
Step 3. Limit what Eun’s reply shows. She put $20 down to hold a slot, and can get it back: one person will reserve now. That does not show she would pay the other $40 when the money cannot come back, and one person says nothing about the rest of the building.
Step 4. Write the honest summary. The wrong one: “Five out of five were positive.” The right one: “Of five replies, one paid a deposit, one gave time and an introduction, one gave an email address, and two cost the sender nothing.” Both describe the same replies, but only the second shows which rung each person reached.
Result
Ana and Ben move nothing. Chloe and Dmitri move the problem assumption a little. Eun is the only reply that touches the pay assumption, and only as a refundable $20 from one person.